‘THE FANTASTICKS’: (left to right) Nathan Levy, Ahmad Simmons, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Zane Phillips, Ruthie Ann Miles & Maxim Chlumecky. Photo: Joan Marcus.
THE FANTASTICKS
Book & lyrics by Tom Jones
Music by Harvey Schmidt
Suggested by Les Romanesques by Edmond Rostand
Revised book & lyrics by Tom Jones
Directed & choreographed by Christopher Gattelli
Through February 7, 2027
Second Stage at the Helen Hayes Theater
240 West 44th Street
https://2st.com/
Adding a new twist to classic plays and musicals is nothing new on Broadway. New York audiences have also become increasingly familiar with productions that explore LGBTQ+ relationships. So, the announcement that Second Stage would present a revamped revival of The Fantasticks certainly raised some curiosity. Best known for the classic song “Try to Remember,” the musical has become a community theater staple nationwide.
The major change transforms the original heterosexual romance into a gay love story. But does the show still have the same emotional impact? The answer is a resounding yes. Thanks to revisions to the book and lyrics and a gifted cast, The Fantasticks remains a charming and wonderfully old-fashioned musical.
Few musicals have enjoyed the longevity of The Fantasticks. Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s intimate musical opened Off-Broadway in 1960 at the Sullivan Street Playhouse in the West Village and became a theatrical institution. Mr. Jones, who died in August 2023 at age 95, also wrote the revised book and lyrics for this version. The new adaptation features two young men as the lovers and replaces their meddling fathers with mothers.
A love story with a twist
Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and Lewis (Nathan Levy) are young neighbors in love, despite an apparent feud between their mothers, Mildred Hucklebee (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer) and Bessie Mae Bellomy. In reality, the women are friends who invented the quarrel to encourage the romance. They hire El Gallo (Zane Phillips) to stage a mock abduction and bring the supposed feud to an end. However, their scheme eventually unravels when the boys discover the truth. As a result, the young lovers must confront the difference between romantic fantasy and real love.
Those unforgettable songs
The plot of The Fantasticks is admittedly convoluted. However, at its heart, the musical remains a whimsical fantasy and a delightful deconstruction of a storybook romance.
Harvey Schmidt’s appealing score is perhaps the main reason The Fantasticks has won the hearts of generations of fans. Hearing Zane Phillips as El Gallo belt out “Try to Remember” in his rich, mellifluous voice during the show’s opening is one of the evening’s highlights. But Mr. Phillips has much more to offer than a terrific singing voice. His commanding stage presence, natural charisma and consistently strong performance make him a captivating El Gallo. Whether narrating the story or interacting with the other characters, he brings confidence and charm to every scene. He’s simply marvelous.
Two young men in love
Mr. Chlumecky and Mr. Levy make a convincing couple, and both have strong singing voices. Mr. Levy particularly shines in their duets, “Metaphor” and “Soon It’s Gonna Rain.”
In the original musical, Luisa dreams of being someone special. She insists that she is “blood royal” rather than an ordinary girl. In this version, Luisa becomes Lewis, who retains the original character’s carefree innocence and romantic idealism. Although Mr. Jones revised portions of the dialogue and lyrics to accommodate the gender change, the character remains essentially the same.
Mr. Levy’s portrayal of Lewis is dramatic and expressive. Yet his performance feels natural rather than campy. Both actors simply portray two young men experiencing the excitement and innocence of first love. Refreshingly, the production never treats their sexuality as an issue. Instead, it focuses on the joys, uncertainties and occasional foolishness of young romance. Perhaps the closest the show comes to camp is Lewis’s amusing infatuation with the hunky, muscular Zane Phillips as El Gallo.
Mothers know best. Or do they?
At the performance I attended, Michele Ragusa appeared as Bessie Mae Bellomy in place of Ruthie Ann Miles, opposite Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer as Mildred Hucklebee. Ms. Ragusa and Ms. Kritzer displayed terrific comic chemistry, particularly in their lively renditions of “Never Say No” and “Plant a Radish.”
Small-scale charm on Broadway
I saw The Fantasticks more than a decade ago at the Jerry Orbach Theater in Midtown, where the long-running Off-Broadway revival played until finally closing in 2017. So, I was pleased that director and choreographer Christopher Gattelli managed to retain the intimacy and small-scale charm I remembered.
The Helen Hayes Theater, one of Broadway’s smaller houses, is a perfect fit for this modest musical. Jason Sherwood’s simple yet picturesque scenic design works beautifully in the space. Meanwhile, Linda Cho’s colorful but understated costumes complement the production without overwhelming it. Mr. Gattelli wisely keeps things from becoming too elaborate.
The supporting performers also add plenty of fun to the evening. Kevin Del Aguila as Mortimer and David Patrick Kelly as Henry, the Old Actor, seem to be having a blast with their comical roles. Meanwhile, Ahmad Simmons earns plenty of applause as the Mute without ever saying a word. He’s especially ebullient and delightful during his tap dance number at the beginning of Act Two.
The magic of love endures
Ultimately, this revised Fantasticks proves that changing the gender of its young lovers does nothing to diminish the show’s heart, charm or timeless message about love. Second Stage’s inventive Broadway revival of this cherished classic offers a wonderful escape from everyday troubles and a chance to spend an enchanted afternoon or evening at the theater.
Published November 21, 2026
Reviewed at press performance on November 19, 2026.