‘NOW YOU SEE ME LIVE’: (left to right) Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, Eden Choi, Gabriella Lester & James More. Photo: Jeremy Daniel.
NOW YOU SEE ME LIVE
Based on the Lionsgate motion picture and characters created by Boaz Yakin and Edward Ricourt
Created by Simon Painter
Directed by Ash Jacks McCready & Kirsty White
Through January 3, 2027
Al Hirschfeld Theatre
302 West 45th Street
https://nowyouseemelive.com/
I have seen plenty of magic and illusionist shows during my 21 years of reviewing Broadway. So, I went into a preview of Now You See Me Live knowing what to expect. Well, sort of. I anticipated a flashy, entertaining spectacle, and I wasn’t wrong.
Since 2014, The Illusionists has brought an international assortment of magicians, mentalists and escape artists to Broadway, usually during the holidays.
Now comes Now You See Me Live, inspired by the popular film franchise. Full disclosure: I’ve never seen any of the films, but don’t be fooled by the Hollywood connection. This production bears a striking resemblance to its Broadway predecessors. Not surprising, since Tim Lawson and Simon Painter, the producers behind The Illusionists, are responsible for this latest extravaganza. The show features a four-person illusion ensemble known as “The Four Horsemen.”
Host Matthew Pomeroy
The bubbly Matthew Pomeroy, a British mentalist, serves as emcee for the 85-minute show. With his crisp accent, amusing jokes and effusive personality, Mr. Pomeroy keeps the evening moving at a lively pace.
For starters, he asks an audience member to surrender an iPhone, which is placed inside one of several envelopes. The envelopes are then stuffed into a blender and shredded. Mr. Pomeroy cuts open a melon and reveals the missing phone inside. It’s a fun trick that sets the tone for an evening of comedy, suspense and audience participation.
Darcy Oake
Canadian illusionist Darcy Oake, who appeared in the 2018 Broadway edition of The Illusionists: Magic of the Holidays, returns with two exciting feats that go well beyond the standard dove tricks he performed back then.
First, he reveals a live scorpion inside a box, puts it in his mouth and appears to swallow it. His mouth is sealed with tape, and his hands are handcuffed behind his back. An audience volunteer slaps Mr. Oake as he escapes from the handcuffs and eventually pulls the nasty creature from his mouth.
Is the scorpion real? Does it still have its stinger? It doesn’t matter. The stunt aims for amusing shock value, and it is certainly jaw-dropping and not for the squeamish.
Mr. Oake’s second feat pays homage to Harry Houdini. Suspended above the stage, he submerges his head in a transparent, water-filled box while his hands are chained and locked. As the seconds tick away on a digital clock, he must free himself before running out of breath. Even knowing such feats are carefully rehearsed, it’s difficult not to feel anxious watching him struggle underwater. The audience, of course, goes wild when he escapes.
Eden Choi
South Korean “next-generation manipulator” Eden Choi is one of the show’s highlights, proving that impressive magic doesn’t require elaborate sets or special effects. Using playing cards and small balls, he makes objects appear, disappear and seemingly materialize out of thin air.
His fingers move with astonishing speed and precision. It’s a fascinating display of sleight of hand, although his time onstage is disappointingly brief.
Gabriella Lester and James More
At just 22, South African-born magician and escape artist Gabriella Lester has already tackled Houdini’s famous upside-down straitjacket escape, appeared on “Penn & Teller: Fool Us” and attracted a reported 100 million monthly views online. Her major illusion here involves entering and exiting a bank vault shown on a video screen. While visually appealing, it’s hardly the evening’s most exciting feat.
British illusionist James More, who appeared in the 2015 Broadway production of The Illusionists, returns with a contraption he claims to have invented at age 12. Calling it a “teleportation machine,” he demonstrates its powers with a lightbulb before turning the experiment on himself. It’s an amusing premise, although the illusion isn’t particularly memorable.
Family-friendly fun
Now You See Me Live, which played in London this past summer and is currently running in Las Vegas at the MGM Grand, is great family-friendly fun. Creative and staging director Ash Jacks McCready and creative director Kirsty White keep the action moving seamlessly at a rapid pace. While seasoned theatergoers may have seen many of these illusions before, there’s still plenty to enjoy. Audience participation is a big part of the fun. Toward the end of the performance, everyone gets to join in a card trick using cards they picked up in the lobby. Anyone who enjoys Vegas-style magic and illusions, complete with dazzling pyrotechnics and large-screen projections, will not be disappointed.
Published November 18, 2026
Reviewed at press performance on November 14, 2026.
‘NOW YOU SEE ME LIVE’: Gabriella Lester in the U.K. production at the London Coliseum. Photos: Johan Persson.